Skip to content
Home » Why does my Americano taste watery?

Why does my Americano taste watery?


Does your Americano taste like it’s lacking character, resembling water more than the rich, robust coffee you were expecting? You are not alone. Many coffee enthusiasts in the UK find themselves puzzled by the lacklustre flavour of their homemade Americano. To understand why this happens and how to fix it, we need to explore several aspects including the coffee-making process, machine quality, and ingredient ratios.


Does Americano taste diluted?

The short answer is: it shouldn’t. An Americano is designed to be a more diluted version of espresso, yes, but it should by no means taste watery. If it does, several factors could be at play:

  1. Quality of Coffee Beans: Sub-par coffee beans can’t produce an excellent Americano.
  2. Grind Size: An improper grind size can compromise extraction, leading to weak coffee.
  3. Water Temperature: The water temperature must be just right for optimal extraction.
  4. Water-to-Coffee Ratio: Too much water can obviously make your Americano taste watery.
  5. Machine Quality: A low-quality machine can’t replicate the high pressure required for a good espresso shot, which forms the base of your Americano.

Quality of Coffee Beans

The UK is home to a growing number of specialty coffee shops and roasters. The choice of coffee beans is crucial. Opt for freshly roasted beans from reputable roasters. Pre-packaged supermarket options are often stale, leading to a poor-tasting Americano.

Grind Size

For a well-balanced Americano, the coffee should be ground to a fine espresso setting. A coarse grind will make your coffee taste weak and watery because the water will pass through the coffee grounds too quickly, failing to extract enough flavour.

Water Temperature

The water temperature should be between 90-96°C. Too hot or too cold water will mess with the extraction process.

Water-to-Coffee Ratio

A typical Americano consists of one or two espresso shots diluted with hot water. The standard ratio is 1:1 for espresso to water, although this can vary depending on personal preferences.

Machine Quality

While you don’t need a high-end espresso machine to make a decent Americano, investing in a quality machine can make a significant difference in taste. Look for machines with good pressure capabilities and user reviews.

What should a good Americano taste like?

A good Americano should offer a balance between strength and dilution. It should have the robustness of espresso but be mellowed out enough to be sipped and savoured like drip coffee. The best Americano will provide a rich aroma, complex flavours, and a pleasant aftertaste.

“A well-brewed Americano should feel like a warm embrace, providing both the punch of espresso and the comfort of a long drink.”

Understanding Flavour Notes

The flavour profile of your Americano will largely depend on the coffee bean’s origin. Beans from different regions bring unique flavour notes like fruity, nutty, chocolatey, or floral. Understanding these flavour notes can help you pick the right coffee for your Americano.

The Art of Dilution

While the dilution factor in an Americano is subjective, many baristas suggest starting with a 1:1 ratio and adjusting to taste. You may prefer a 1:2 or even a 1:3 ratio, but these variations should never lead to a watery taste.

Timing is Everything

The extraction time for the espresso shot should be between 25-30 seconds. Any shorter or longer, and you risk compromising flavour. Use a timer if you need to, as the timing is essential for a good Americano.

Consistency is Key

The more consistently you can reproduce the conditions for brewing, the more consistent the flavour of your Americano will be. Whether you’re using a manual espresso maker or a fully automated one, keeping everything from the grind size to the water temperature consistent is key to avoiding a watery taste.

AspectWhat To DoWhat To Avoid
BeansFreshly roasted, high-quality beansStale, low-quality beans
Grind SizeFine espresso grindCoarse grind
Water Temperature90-96°CToo hot or too cold
Water-to-Coffee Ratio1:1 ratio to start, adjust to tasteToo much water

In conclusion, if your Americano tastes watery, there are various elements to consider and adjust. From the quality of the coffee beans to the water-to-coffee ratio, minor tweaks can lead to significant improvements in flavour. Happy brewing!